Members 1st Federal Credit Union Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg

Members 1st Federal Credit Union Reviews

• M

  Michael Comiskey
  1

  Awful. 2 tellers and a manager. 2 people at the window when I got there one person in front of me. Took 15 minutes to finally get called to a window. 2 of those were after the last person left and the manager and teller were having side conversations before they called me up. Asked for my withdrawal gave I’d and account number. Teller barely addressed me as he was too busy talking to his manager complaining about something and it being the “principal of it”. Doesn’t give me my money in the bills i requested. Literally he took my ID and tossed it back to me. Not placing it down not setting it in front of me. Tossed it down while he continued to complain about his nonsense while the line behind me grew to 7 people. This location is terrible.

  Response from the owner

  Hi Michael Comiskey, we are sorry to hear about your experience and our team would like to take a closer look at your situation. Please email us at [email protected]. Thank you.

• s

  shdyldy
  5

  There was no wait for ATM services.

  Response from the owner

  Thanks for being a member, shdyldy!

• A

  Andrew Smith
  5

  Great experience in speaking with Shawn, listened to my problems and helped me understand activity in my account. He made the whole process easy and soley because of him, I have to give this customer service 5 stars. If all employees were like him, I have no doubt this credit union would be twice the size.

• M

  Miller Million
  1

  1) Terrible policy, terms and conditions, and follow through of written policies from upper management of the branch. (They had all rights to waive any and/or all fees). 2) My account was dinged 59 overdraft fees on 59 $10 transactions. $320 was actually deducted from my account and paid to the merchants on my behalf. So I became responsible for 32 overdraft fees. $1184 in overdraft fees over $320 charged to the members of the credit union. That is roughly a profit to Members 1st of $900. 3) I had deposited funds to cover any and all transactions roughly 10 minutes after they processed through pending activity (I tried to beat the time frame I thought I had which was 11pm and they dinged at 5pm). I was literally 10 minutes too late (5:10pm deposit). My $1200 deposit was basically taken away by fees. $16 of the deposit went towards any of the charges on my plate. 4) Upper management did not honor the mistake of timing. They accepted a $900 profit of my mistakes. 5) Credit Unions are ran and funded by members. Mostly on interest rates. They are tax exempt entities, unlike banks. They claim to be “Not-For-Profit”. They profited $900 on my behalf. I paid back everything to the members of the union 10 minutes after they were “affected”. 6) Almost all other banks and/or credit unions have maximum overdraft fees per business day. Most are 4-5 overdraft fees MAX on any given business day. This “bank”went 8x’s (literally was 14x's to begin with) that rate on me. 7) This whole issue is totally unjust and very inconsiderate on the upper management of the branch. The terms say they have the rights to waive any and/or all fees. They hardly helped me out at all... 8) The First thing they did to fix the issue, is all that they did for the matter! Even after 7 days of waiting for a return phone call. In conclusion, stay far away from this “bank” their policies are unjust and upper management left me high and dry when I was 10 minutes late on my funds being deposited. Look elsewhere to local banks such as PNC bank, or M&T bank because they do have Maximum Overdraft Fees per Day!

  Response from the owner

  We have appreciated the opportunity to discuss this matter with you over the past several days. We have heard your frustrations, and have taken steps to help resolve your issue. If you have further concerns, please use the contact that was previously provided to you.

• E

  Eric T
  1

  Worst customer service I’ve ever experienced at a bank. Female teller behind counter was extremely rude. Loudly talked about my finances in front of other customers. They will take any chance they can to charge you a fee.

  Response from the owner

  Hello Eric T, we're sorry to hear about your experience and would like the opportunity to discuss it further. Please call our customer service line at (800) 283-2328 so we can help. Thank you!

• K

  Kelle Grove
  5

  I absolutely love this bank!! I am not a fan of the lobby being closed though.. but its to protect themselves and others so I understand!!! Stay safe and thanks for your help! 😁😁

  Response from the owner

  Thank you for reviewing us, Kelle Grove! We’re glad to be a part of your financial journey.

• N

  Nolan Sheely
  5

  5 stars solely because of drive thru teller named Cody. Excellent customer service skills. Friendly and helpful every time.

  Response from the owner

  Hi Nolan Sheely, thank you for taking the time to tell us about your experience and thank you for being a member!

• B

  Baywand Sdiq
  1

  Do not recommend this bank ! New updated... I have many accounts with them plus my business account 4 years ago and right now i requested to loan 100k for my new business with my paid off house 300k value in market now And they asking for to many regulations for no reason 😒

  Response from the owner

  Thank you for being a member, Baywand!

• B

  Becky Short
  1

  Monday may 10th I drove to two locations the Simpson Ferry and Carlisle Pike locations both of them were closed prior to 5. Both the lobby and the drive-through were closed I checked online prior to leaving my home their hours and it clearly states 9 to 5 absolutely no mention of them being closed. A small note taped on the door. Obviously this credit union does not care about their members time. Very unprofessional

• C

  Christopher Crowley
  4

  What can you say about using an ATM that you don't have to leave your car. Convenient.

  Response from the owner

  Thanks for the positive review, C J Crowley!