Cassidy's Fish Market Bayview Ave, Barnegat Light

Cassidy's Fish Market Reviews

• A

  Asher Puth
  5

  Cassidy’s is the best place to buy seafood. The staff here is super friendly and the quality of the product is excellent. This is the best place around! Enjoy!

• R

  Raquel M
  5

  Picked up some tile fish and clams. Both delicious, tasty and very fresh.

• D

  David Moskowitz
  5

  Great variety of fish & shellfish... And mini-key lime pies, too. Cash or check only, & the ATM at Viking Village charges $3.99 for withdrawal.

• J

  J R
  2

  Buyer Beware! I have been living in Barnegat Light for 26 years and have always seen a spike in pricing during the vacation season at Cassidy's but today they are DOUBLE what they were 3 weeks ago. Tuna steaks $40.99 a pound? Scallops U-10s $39.99 a pound, small scallops $29.99 a pound??? Today is the first time I ever walked out empty handed and went to the mainland for fish. Vacationing folks before you come to the island get your fish at home. So sad great fresh fish but way overpriced.

• J

  James Ward
  1

  To my Disbelief, I watched a young worker take off his hat, run his hand through his hair, put his hat back on and asked me if I needed help,,, Ill take 2 lbs of scallops, with the same dirty hand he reaches in the scallop dish and grabs a handful and puts them in a bag,, WAIT !! what are you doing? Wheres Your Glove ? the Manager walks over and says We Dont Use a Glove when we handle Scallops,,WHAT !, You Will if your selling them to me ! so the manager says put on a glove, (the pack of disposable gloves was right in front of the display) so the kid gloves up, then grabs another handful of scallops and puts them in the same bag with the dirty ones ,, Hell NO, im not paying $28.99 lb for Dirty Scallops .Period. So I said Forget It and Walked Out. Incidentally while I waited for the store to open, I watched the same kid walk out front to the strip carrying an Open Flag, he came back in and Never Washed his Hands ! Food Handlers Must Wash there Hands and Wear Gloves When Needed,, BTW, the Prices Are OUTRAGOUSE ! Vacationers Your getting Ripped Off In A BIG Way, Quality, Cleanliness,And Price, I Too went off the Island to the Mainland and bought scallops for $5 less per lb

• J

  Jeff C.
  5

  If you like scallops then this is the place to go for them! I don't know about any other fish or seafood that they sell because I have never gotten anything other than scallops here. Its a half hour drive for me but its well worth it. They are a little higher in price but I don't mind spending a little more for the quality you get. Highly recommend for the scallops!!

• N

  Natalia Spinelli
  5

  Local sea scallops!!! Fresh! Open daily! Great service. They take credit cards. Ask which locally caught fish they have available as well. Plenty of parking. Easy in & out.

• E

  Emmet Flanigan
  5

  I have been coming to Cassidy’s fish market for over 35 years and it still blows me away every time. The scallops are so fresh they’ll whisper sweet nothings into your ear if you hold them close enough. The staff is friendly and never short on delicious recipe recommendations (it doesn’t hurt that they are cute as well). The crab cakes are to die for and the key lime pie has been known to make grown men weep. If I could give them 11/5 stars I would.

• M

  M Raso K
  5

  Can be pricey but you can’t beat their freshness. Scallops are a local staple but all the fish is good.

• E

  Eric Delmar
  5

  Best seafood market on Long Beach Island, and probably the state. Family-run and always friendly. Been shopping here for decades. They've made grand many family dinners in my house. Soft shell crabs tonight!