Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. Conestoga Ave, Honey Brook

Blue Marsh Insurance, Inc. Reviews

• N

  Nyeshia McQueen
  5

  I am not even sure where I want to begin. Talk about AWESOME service. Blue Marsh has given me confidence great service and great people in organizations still exist! Mickie is attentive and friendly when I have loads of questions, the rates offered are terrific and the all around service was just about perfect. So many companies and organizations today hire ANYONE to perform service, most lacking the basic customer service skills to win and maintain customers. Can't say that about Blue Marsh. I had an OUTSTANDING experience and recommend (big or small) other companies look to find out what they do to make their employees happy so (in turn) the team works to make the customers happy! You have my vote again and again! I am already telling others about you all! Keep up the fantastic work!

  Response from the owner

  We cannot thank you enough for this thoughtful review of our team at Blue Marsh! It is our absolute pleasure you have you as a client! Thank you for spreading the word about Blue Marsh - it means the world to us.

• S

  Slicknick Longacre
  5

  Katie is the best, insurance protection advisor i ever had. She is always quick to respond, and always has answers for my questions or concerns. If she doesn’t have the answers she will let me know that she will find out and get back to me. shes very delightful and diligent. I recommend her to everyone i talk too. I plan to be her client for many years to come. Where ever she goes, I go.

  Response from the owner

  WOW. This is an incredible review for Katie. Thank you so much for taking the time to write this! We are so proud of her and are thrilled you are so happy with the service you are receiving!

• S

  Stephen Maylie
  5

  We’ve been a part of Blue Marsh for 6 years now. From renters insurance, to home insurance (including a mortgage refi) and auto insurance they handle everything for us and we could not be happier. In person, on the phone, or email the team is always super responsive to our inquires and very easy to work with. Tom, Katie, and Erika have helped us several times and we look forward to staying with them for a very long time.

  Response from the owner

  Wow Stephen, thank you so much for this fantastic review! It means a ton that you've been a long-term client and have trusted us with your insurance policies throughout your life changes. Thank you!!

• L

  Lynne Sutter
  5

  I've been with blue marsh for I think 3-4 years now. My agent is Katie. She is amazing! I've never had any issues. Anything I call her for is taken care of promptly and professionally. I 10/10 recommend blue marsh insurance and my agent Katie!

  Response from the owner

  This is fantastic, Lynne! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a review. It means a ton!

• A

  Amanda Buzzard
  5

  I love working with Blue Marsh for all of our insurance needs. They always take a look at our rates every year to make sure we have the right coverage and we aren't over paying. I would highly recommend Blue Marsh to anyone in need of insurance.

  Response from the owner

  Your recommendation means so much to us! We really appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review!

• M

  Mary Ann Campbell
  5

  I called to request a quote for homeowners and auto. I spoke to Mickie and she was very prompt and professional in getting a quote to me. She answered all our questions making it very easy to understand. My husband and I went to her office to meet Mickie and sign the paperwork. The office environment was very nice and Mickie was awesome!!

  Response from the owner

  We are so happy to hear this and are so glad that you had such a wonderful experience with Mickie. Thanks for taking the time to leave us a review. It means a ton!

• K

  Kristen Naugle
  5

  Mickie Shimp has been fantastic to work with. She helped us find the best insurance for the best price. And when we had to make a claim for our broken windshield, she made it quick, easy and pain free.

  Response from the owner

  We are so happy to hear about the awesome experience you've had with Mickie! Thanks for sharing! It means a ton to us.

• D

  Denny Emrick
  5

  We have been insured with Blue Marsh for more than 10 years. They provide us great advice and service. Mickie Shimp is a great asset to a company full of competent people!!!

  Response from the owner

  Wow, Denny - what a wonderful review! Thank you for being such a loyal client and for sharing your Blue Marsh experience. We appreciate you!

• R

  Russ Scaramastra
  5

  Katie at Blue Marsh Insurance is a real Pro. She understood my needs and communicated clearly. I will recommend Katie and Blue Marsh to everyone. Thx Russ Scaramastra

  Response from the owner

  We can't tell you how much your recommendation means to us, Russ! Thank you so much for taking the time to write this review and give us 5-stars. We appreciate you!

• D

  Dave Culbert
  5

  Katie Sheaffer is a pleasure to work with. Communication is excellent and the honesty and transparency is evident at this company. Thanks so much.

  Response from the owner

  Dave, thank you so much for noticing. You're right - honesty with our customers is one of our top priorities. Thanks for taking the time to leave us a review!